It's Election Day, and voters across the United States are busy renewing their whining privileges for the next four years. This election year could also deliver some interesting--and perhaps ugly--experiences with electronic voting systems.

E-voting systems, most of which are supplied by four private vendors, will count nearly a third of the votes cast nationwide in today's elections. All four vendors use proprietary e-voting software, all of which is subject to government-approved auditing and review procedures. These firms also, however, jealously protect the source code behind their e-voting systems, and critics have charged that the certification process is incomplete, under-funded, and susceptible to vendor manipulation.

One of the biggest e-voting vendors, Diebold Systems, illustrates almost everything that could go wrong with proprietary e-voting software. Diebold was caught using non-certified software, and the company stands accused of leaving its systems exposed to a variety of security failures and software hacks. The California state attorney general filed a lawsuit against Diebold for selling shoddy e-voting software, and BlackBoxVoting.org, an e-voting advocacy group, recently showed a video demonstrating how a chimpanzee (really!) could erase audit logs on one of the company's e-voting machines.

E-Voting Vendors, Foes Count Down To Election Day

All of this raises the question: Could open-source e-voting software do a better job? Many watchdog groups, including BlackBoxVoting.org and Open Voting Consortium, believe open-source software provides the best way to guarantee truly secure, trustworthy elections. The open-source development model would, for example, ensure that developers find and fix potential security flaws, rather than ignoring or burying them.

Group Pushes Open-Source E-Voting Software

Yet even if both models produced equally secure software, we're not just talking about an app server for someone's widget company. We're talking about the system that decides who governs the United States, from local school boards to the presidency. I have a serious problem turning over the democratic process to companies that treat vote-counting as a trade secret.

Even so, I worry that open-source alternatives could run into trouble if they aren't prepared to deal with the political as well as the technological aspects of this process. In fact, an open-source e-voting initiative could easily turn into an unmitigated disaster.

I'm not saying that the current system works: When a company like Diebold can exhibit such willful stupidity, yet remain a legitimate option for counting the nation's votes, it's time for a change. Bear in mind, however, that open-source software won't automatically solve the problem of how to create a foolproof audit trail for election results--one of the biggest controversies surrounding e-voting. Also remember that this isn't just about creating software code; it's about handling a high-explosive mix of technology, public expectations, and partisan politics, along with a lot of people who will do their very best to ensure the system fails miserably.

Is the open-source community ready to deal with all of this? Do any of us really understand just how treacherous this process will be? I have my doubts. But by the time you read this, we'll probably know whether proprietary e-voting solutions can do any better--or any worse.

Matthew McKenzie
Editor, Linux Pipeline
mattcmp@sonic.net
www.LinuxPipeline.com

UK Gives Open Source The OK
A UK government report gives agencies the go-ahead to consider open-source alternatives to proprietary software.

Group Pushes Open-Source E-Voting Software
The Open Voting Consortium says open-source provides the best way to create secure, trustworthy electronic voting systems.

Ballmer Confronts Linux Challenge
The Microsoft CEO argues the case for Windows vs. Linux in an email to customers and partners.

Dell Adds SuSE To Linux Server Line
The longtime Microsoft partner joins other major OEMs in pre-installing Novell's enterprise Linux offering.

Red Hat Looks To The Data Center
With its Enterprise Linux 3 release, Red Hat aims to deliver a viable platform for large-scale enterprise applications.

MySQL Update Ready To Roll
After months of testing, MySQL AB releases the latest version of its open-source business database server.

Microsoft's Linux Letter
The full text of last week's letter from Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer to the company's customers.

CA Releases Open-Source Database
Computer Associates ships an open-source version of its Ingres database for Linux and Windows.

Mandrakesoft Ships Linux OS Update
The company's Mandrakelinux 10.1 Official release includes improved mobile device support and hardware compatibility.

IBM Joins Liberty Alliance
IBM's decision reflects growing support for creating an open enterprise identity-management standard.

Microsoft Offers Sender ID Compromise
Microsoft makes changes to its Sender ID proposal, including one intended to address criticism from the Apache Foundation.

Security Pipeline: E-Voting Vendors, Foes Count Down To Election Day
E-voting system vendors face mounting concerns about the integrity of their products.

How-To: Make MySQL Sing
MySQL can provide administrators with amazing amounts of performance information. Here's how to get it.

By The Numbers: Open-Source Software Joins The Mix
From the Fortune 500 to the corner store, research shows that open-source products have a firm foothold in U.S. companies.

Expert Advice: Educate Or Litigate
Better education and more careful research could largely prevent legal problems for open-source software users.

Case Study: Open Source Runs The Space Race
From email to AI, the world's space programs are getting a major boost from open-source software.

Check Out Our Linux Product Finder
Don't reinvent the wheel. Find the right off-the-shelf product to do the job. How do you find the right one? Two words ... Product Finder:
   - Desktop Applications
   - Application Servers
   - Commercial Linux Distributions
   - Network Management
   - Web Servers

Discover All The Pipelines
Linux Pipeline is part of a large series of specialized IT sites from the TechWeb Network. Find out more about the Pipelines on the TechWeb Network Pipeline Publications page. Every Pipeline site has its own newsletter. Give them a try!

Recommend This Newsletter To A Friend
Do you have a friend or colleague who might enjoy this newsletter? Please forward it to him or her and point out the subscription page.